John Deere Vs Simplicity: Which Brand to Choose?

You have probably heard about both brands as they offer premium landscaping equipment of different types. When it comes to John Deere vs simplicity, people often wonder, which one should one choose?

In terms of special features, durability, sturdy frame, and warranty, you should definitely choose John Deere. But simplicity also has a loyal fanbase due to its good-quality affordable tractors.

They are US-based companies that don’t compromise the quality. In this article, I have shown the difference between JD and simplicity which would help tractor or mower buyers.

John Deere Vs Simplicity: Quick Comparison Table

 John DeereSimplicity
ManufacturerJohn DeereBriggs and Stratton
Engine Power17.5 – 25.5 HP23 – 27 HP
Mower Deck Size42”-54”38”-52”
Seat AdjustabilityYesYes
Warranty2 years/120 hours3 years std.
Overall ComfortGoodGood
Overall EfficiencyEfficientEfficient
Handling AbilityGoodGood
PriceLower than SimplicityHigher than John Deere
ReliableYesYes

What’s the Difference Between Kioti and Bobcat Tractor Based on Features?

Manufacturer:

JD or John Deere is a good and reputed brand that began its journey in 1837. The company is named after its founder John Deere.

What I love about the company is that it is centered around its customers. The design philosophy and improvements are beneficial to its users.

In a survey done by Consumer Reports, John Deere won the award for the most reliable brand for lawn tractors and ZTR mowers.

Simplicity is a good brand for many reasons that I’m going to explain here.

Founder William J. Niederkorn started the company in 1922 and started making walk-behind two-wheeled tractors in 1937.

After the production problems during the second world war, Simplicity started its production again in 1957.

The famous Briggs & Stratton bought the company in 2004. But they announced closing down their production facility in 2008.

Engine Power:

In the lawn tractor segment, both John Deere and Simplicity have several models. And, you can choose from a wide range of engine power.

In JD’s product lineup, there are 4 series; 100, 200, X300, and X500. The most basic model starts from 17.5 HP.

And, the largest and most expensive models from the X500 series have up to 25.5 HP.

Here, Simplicity offers more powerful engines in their lawn tractors. This brand doesn’t have much model variation like JD.

There are 4 models to choose from where one can get the highest power from Prestige™ Garden Tractor; 27 HP.

Mower Deck Size:

In this mower deck size comparison part, I have nothing much to add because both brands have almost similar deck-size options.

The smallest cutting width is available in Simplicity; 38 inches whereas JD tractors start from 42 inches deck size.

In the largest mower cutting deck size, John Deere aces; 54 inches. And, Simplicity offers a 52” deck in its most expensive lawn tractor model; Prestige.

Seat Adjustment:

For added comfort, both JD and Simplicity provide adjustable seats with their tractors and Zero Turn Mowers.

But don’t expect much from their low-end models. To match the pricing, these companies provide basic seats with not many adjustable features.

That changes in the X500 series and Simplicity Prestige. Here, the seat cushioning is softer, has better suspension, and adjustable levers.

The ergonomic mesh seats ensure airflow keeps you cool and help you sit for long hours.

Warranty:

The basic lawn tractors from John Deere have 2 years or 120 hours of bumper to bumper warranty. Get more info from this official link.

The best thing is that expensive models have a longer warranty period which leads up to 4 hours or 500 hours; whichever comes first.

On the other hand, Simplicity doesn’t differentiate in their products as all four models come with a standard 3-year warranty.

I would recommend you to read the user manual and know more about the terms and conditions of the warranty before making a final decision.

For mowers and tractors, a warranty is very important because there are thousands of tiny parts that are ready to be non-functional at any time.

Overall Comfort:

If you watch the products from Simplicity and John Deere, you will notice that they come with great suspension systems, and all comfort features one needs.

According to my research, the lower-end less expensive models are not that good in terms of comfort, but people are satisfied with the performance of expensive ones.

Overall Efficiency:

Both brands use engines from various manufacturers. And, the companies are in business for years making fine-tuned engines.

So, you can expect high-efficiency levels from them. The deck design and matched engine power help keep the fuel consumption low.

Handling Ability:

As you know that both brands are making mowers and tractors for a long time, and they have managed to perfect the controlling system.

All buttons and switches to ride and maneuver are close to the driver. So, anyone can easily do the landscaping job.

Whether you go for a John Deere or Simplicity product, it won’t take much time to adapt the settings.

Price:

There is a noticeable price difference between John Deere and Simplicity lawn tractors and mowers.

In the beginning segment, you will find an almost $1400 price gap between similar models.

And, in the higher-up models, the gap can reach $2200 or more. I’m not mentioning the exact prices because the market price varies from state to state.

For those who are looking for a budget option, I think that John Deere will be a good choice for them.

Reliability:

Both Simplicity and John Deere are reliable brands but there are lot of negative feedback from JD users.

Simplicity also is not perfect but their customers are overall happy with the durable and reliable performance.

And, I think that it is understandable considering their prices. Though paying more doesn’t always mean a good thing, it is true in this case.

I would recommend saving some more and trying to go with a Simplicity mower or lawn tractor for tension-free services.

John Deere or Simplicity: Which Brand to Choose? (The Verdict)

You have reached the end of the John Deere vs Simplicity comparison.

After analyzing different products, customer feedback, and the history of both brands, I think that I can make certain recommendations.

If you don’t have a budget problem, want reliable engine performance, and can’t compromise with the modern features of a tractor, you must choose John Deere.

And, those who are okay with the Briggs and Stratton engines, have a tight budget, and as the customer support of Simplicity can choose this brand.

So, what do you think? Which one will serve you the best? Let me know in the comments below.

Related Posts: